커뮤니티 Q&A

Audiokinetic의 커뮤니티 Q&A 포럼에 오신 것을 환영합니다. 이 포럼은 Wwise와 Strata 사용자들이 서로 도움을 주는 곳입니다. Audiokinetic의 직접적인 도움을 얻으려면 지원 티켓 페이지를 사용하세요. 버그를 보고하려면 Audiokinetic 런처에서 Bug Report 옵션을 사용하세요. (Q&A 포럼에 제출된 버그 보고는 거절됩니다. 전용 Bug Report 시스템을 사용하면 보고 내용이 담당자에게 정확히 전달되어 문제 해결 가능성이 크게 높아집니다.)<segment 6493>

빠르고 정확한 답변을 얻으려면 질문을 올릴 때 다음 팁을 참고하세요.

  • 구체적인 내용을 적어주세요: 무엇을 하려는지, 혹은 어떤 특정 문제에 부딪혔는지 설명하세요.
  • 핵심 정보를 포함하세요: Wwise와 게임 엔진 버전, 운영체제 등 관련 정보를 함께 제공하세요.
  • 시도한 방법들을 알려주세요: 문제 해결을 위해 이미 어떤 단계를 시도해봤는지 설명해주세요.
  • 객관적인 사실에 초점을 맞추세요: 문제의 기술적 사실을 중심으로 설명하세요. 문제에 집중할수록 다른 사람들이 더 빠르게 해결책을 찾을 수 있습니다.

0 투표
Is there a way to prevent Wwise from processing the input audio files through the conversion settings during Soundbank generation. I am doing some testing and I want to make sure the exact same input file is playing during game playback.

Currently I am using the default conversion settings that sets the Sample Rate 'As Input'. The file I am using is 48k and is 2.7MB before conversion. The output file is still 48k and 1.8MB in size. How do I prevent this compression from happening?
General Discussion Stephen F. (200 포인트) 로 부터

1 답변

0 투표
 
우수 답변
Hi Stephen,

Firstly note that all files will undergo a slight transformation ( even linear PCM .wav files ) into AK's native .wem format ( which is similar to RIFF/WAVE format ).

I'm assuming that your input files are broadcast wave files or have some other wasted data and so when wwise does the conversion the output file is smaller as only the required metadata is included.

If you want to check this yourself; set the file to stream, build the bank and the compare the .wem file with your original file. If you would like me to do the comparision for you let me know.

In conclusion it is very likely that the data saving you are seeing is not the result of lossy data compression, as you fear, but as a result of cleaning up the file.

Hope that helps,

Dan Murray
Dan M. (2.6k 포인트) 로 부터
선택됨 Stephen F. 로 부터
Thank you for this answer and that totally makes sense.

I am curious how you would do the comparison. I can't do a diff because the files are binary and I can't import the .wem file into a DAW to do a phase inversion test. What way would you do this comparison?

Also, I want to make sure I am looking at the correct .wem file. When I set it to stream and generated the sound bank there was a numerical file (942515203.wem) in the GeneratedSoundBanks/[Platform]/ folder. Additionally, the number is the ID of the Streamed File in the soundbank xml. It additionally looks like the same size as the "compressed" file that Wwise generates so I am thinking it is the correct one.

Lastly, I did a print from Unity/Wwise out to ProTools over AES/EBU and did a phase inversion comparison with the original file and found that there is some added noise (negligable -125dB) on the recorded file between both Unity on its own and Unity with Wwise integrated. I am wondering if both systems are applying some sort of dither-like noise on the output. I honestly have no idea. I would be happy to share screen shots.
Even though its a binary file it still has structure to be compared, I would look at the metadata ( other than the audio samples ) to see what's changed and if that removes a large amount of data or not.

If you want to quickly get the short id for a file shift-right-mouse click on the audio in the actor-mixer hierarchy and copy short id. Alternatively you can perform a query for that short id. It sounds like you have the right one either way.

If your input file is 24 bit dithering or truncation will be applied down to 16 bit depending on the conversion settings you use, the default is to apply dither. Additionally the default is to remove DC bias so be aware of that.
...